1.15.2019

Januarage

I had big ideas about what it was going to be like in January 2019.  I prepared myself - I knew the deluge was coming.  Diet posts, whole 30 posts, boot camp, exercise, eating "right," pictures of salads, and more salads, and on and on and on.

This would be the year that I pushed back.  I would banish the #whole30 #cleaneating #moralvaluesassignedtofood #loveyourselfdon'tyouloveyourselfwhyarentyoujoiningagym #DIDYOUFORGETYOURETOOFAT posts, I would block liberally and un-follow often.  I would reclaim this first month of the year and remind the world that loving yourself and your life is not about pounds and inches.

And still... it's halfway through January now, and here I am.  I don't feel energetic, or enlightened, or above it.  I feel...  somewhere between unprepared, sad, angry, and... tired.  I'm so tired.

I'm tired of being told by society that I am dirty and bad because I am not trying to lose weight.

When I read about "clean" eating, it's kind of impossible for my brain not to realize that means you think the way anyone who doesn't eat that way is UN-clean.  Which is inherently negative.

When you talk about treating your body "right" or "with respect" by dieting, you're implying that if I don't do those things, I am wrong and don't respect my body.

I realize that it may feel to some people like I'm exaggerating here, but I'm not.  I'm telling you what it feels like to be surrounded by diet culture, especially when it's not something you buy into.  Diet culture applies MORALS to food, which, let's be honest, is where a lot of eating disorders get started.

I'm tired of being singled out because I'm fat even though no one has any way to know how healthy I am, and even if I am unhealthy it's not anybody's business.  It is just as likely that the person sitting next to me who can fit into a pair of size 6 jeans has bigger health problems than I do.  But because of the way I look, I am assumed not only to be unhealthy, but responsible for my lack of health.

I'm tired of people acting like if I just worked harder to lose weight, I could get it off and keep it off.  That if I just had a little bit more resolve in my resolution, a little more oomph and commitment, it would solve all my problems!  Okay, to be honest, there's a fine line between being tired of these things and just being steam-coming-out-the-ears rage-grimace angry.

My friend Jillian has been posting what she's coined JanuaRant™ every day this month.  She is the type of friend and advocate we all need, and she's dismantling and highlighting the problems with diet culture and the entire shit-show that is January/Resolutions/Weight Loss/Diet Culture/Fat Unacceptance.  I have shared a few of them on my Facebook page, and the other day she posted about weight loss.  Let's take a look, because it hit me like a ton of bricks and activated my super-special-gooey-anger-center.
JanuaRant™: Is it possible to lose weight intentionally, through behavioral changes? You can do the research yourself; I'm limited by a lack of scientific background and a lack of access to some of these papers. But the reviews seem to indicate success rates around 5%. 
And how do they define "success" in these studies, anyway? Sometimes it's a pretty low bar. It varies from study to study, but it might be something like losing 10% of your body weight and keeping it off for a year. 
So if a person who weighs 300 lbs gets down to 270 and stays there for a year, that's success. But where are they in two years? Five years? Forty years? The studies don't usually watch past a year or two. 
(Ten years down the line, that unusually "successful" 270 lb person walks into a new doctor's office. Is that person treated like an "after" picture, a success story? Or is that person badgered about their weight just as much as they were at 300 lbs?) It's not impossible to lose weight intentionally. It's very unlikely, but it's not impossible.
Shit.

You guys.  There are SO many factors at play in people's weights.  Environment, genetics, nature, nurture, psychology, food intake, exercise, hormones, medical conditions, and who knows what else.

When I think about the amount of time I have spent in my life feeling shitty about myself and my inability to be a smaller human, it is maddening.

The amount of time, effort, money, heartache, shame, despair, and bigotry I have spent and experienced in my life about trying to lose weight when the likelihood of success was less than 5%... I'm not sure whether I want to cry or scream.  It's awful, and painful, and insane.  And it makes me so sad for all the people who hate themselves the way that they are.  It makes me so, so angry for all the girls (and boys) who will grow up into this, and never even realize that it ISN'T THEM, that the culture and the expectation is one of the biggest lies they'll ever be told.

Of the small number of people who manage to lose weight intentionally and keep it off, half gain it back.  For your body, that means weight cycling, which has negative health effects.  I've lost and gained 25-50 pounds several times and now, here I sit.  At the same weight for years.  Like... maybe this is just how I am?  What negative effects on my body could have been prevented if I hadn't yo-yo'd?  There's no way to know.

I'm tired of being told to lose weight. 

I had an eye doctor appointment at the end of December.  I had already postponed it once because it's SO tiresome, going in and getting checked for a condition that's completely in remission and being told to lose weight.  I didn't really want to go, but I did anyway.  And sure enough, he checks my eyes, which look great, nothing to see here, folks.  But then he says it.

"How are you doing with fitness and losing weight?"

AGAIN WITH THIS.

This time, though, I spoke.

"You know, it's not really a priority for me.  I lost weight when I was severely symptomatic and it didn't affect the condition."

I didn't look him in the eyes when I said it, but... baby steps right?

He talked some more about how even a 5% weight loss can really help people.  Like, even though I'd suprised him with a different answer than he expected, he couldn't stop himself from making sure that I WAS AWARE THAT WEIGHT LOSS IS THE PRIMARY TREATMENT!!!!  AND WE DON'T WANT IT TO COME BACK!!

Yeah... okay, man.  The thing is, the condition is called idiopathic intracranial hypertension for a reason.  Idiopathic means they have no idea why it happens or how to stop it.  There's no cure.  So, why exactly is weight loss the primary treatment?  Because in some percentage of people, a 5% weight loss helps, and that's the only thing they can grasp at other than diuretics and shunts and other band aids.

They think the condition might be hormone related, but my hormones are wack, and have been for a long time.  That's likely the reason that I'm fat in the first place.  So, thanks for asking me how it's going to just change the way my body naturally works, man.  That's super helpful.

So.  I wanted to feel strong this month, to remember that I have days when the amount of love I feel for myself surpasses any of this fatigue or anger or madness.  I wanted to be an advocate for shiny happy things like loving yourself and happiness in all months instead of the revolving resolution escalator.

It turns out, I'm not ready yet.  I'm not done being mad.  So, here's to a new year, and all the Januarage I can muster.

7.16.2018

Revolution, Revelation: Living in Dietland

This weekend, I met Plum Kettle.  With some time to myself, I decided to try out Dietland.  I devoured the first 8 episodes like I would devour Plum's chocolate layer cake were it in front of me right now.

Plum's experiences and feelings hit incredibly close to home.  The heart and soul connection to Plum was almost immediate.  How could I take my eyes off a character I can identify so strongly with?  Finally, she is here.

Finally, a show about being fat that isn't about either using size as comedic relief or a plot device centered around weight loss.

Finally, a woman I can root for, really root for, because there is so much about her that is me.

Finally, a woman who decides to break the mold instead of shrinking to conform to it, a woman who is real and who is learning to be unapologetic about existing.

Plum on the bed in the throes of her withdrawal from antidepressants rolls over and her shirt rides up, exposing the soft skin of her stomach.  It is a revelation.  Such a small thing, but so overwhelming, to see skin like mine, there as part of the full scene, a moment, just a piece, not exploited, not for humor, not to shock, just a matter of friction and movement but so unheard of on TV.  Or anywhere.

I am fat.  I won't apologize for using that word, even if it makes some people uncomfortable.  Fat is not a bad word.  It's a description.  It is not the antithesis of beautiful or of healthy or of worthy.
Plum: I don't want to be a glamazon. I just want to get on an airplane and not have to apologize to the person I sit next to. I want to go to a bar and get hit on by some bald guy, and I want us to argue whether said bald guy is actually into me or whether he just wants to get laid.
Steven: I know.
Plum: You don't, Steven! You can't! Going off Y, I got my feelings back, and it made me remember why I wanted 'em gone.
This is my life too.  Talking to people who try to understand is like walking into a glass pane and expecting to go through it, the way seems clear but you are unable to proceed.  You may sympathize, or even empathize, but the feeling of sitting at my desk listening to coworkers half my size talk about how they want to lose weight just to be more fit, not for looks and about which diets work and the "science" behind them is one I cannot explain to you.  The feeling of friends 100 or 150 pounds lighter complaining about being fat or their pants not fitting is dehumanization.  It is confirmation that I am outside the circle of normal.  I am not a part of this conversation.  The world tells me that I should not exist this way, that I am what acceptable people are afraid of, the worst fate they can imagine.
Everyday I walk around in this skin people look at me like I have the plague. They act like I'm a stain. They stare and laugh and yell, and worst of all, they tell me I have such pretty face and then they lecture me on how I can fix my body because how I am is wrong. - Plum
When someone doesn't like something I've done, they don't just call me a bitch.  I am a FAT bitch.  When I deny a man's advances, he decides I am an ugly cow, no one would want to fuck me anyway and I will die fat and alone.  The words curl, smoke, and stink of disgust and vitriol, they hate what I am, they hate the body I walk in every day.  How do you survive in a world that bombards you with that, and not start to hate yourself even just a little bit?

In the museum of my life, there is an entire wing made up of paintings and moving pictures of my wrongness, the snippets are burned in my memory for always.

This frame holds the moment I first asked for a seatbelt extender on an airplane.

This screen replays the exasperated defeat and disappointment in finding that the "plus" department only reaches size 24.

This photo captures me sitting alone, knowing that my blind date showed up and left because they did not like what they saw.

On this wall, a photomosaic of the faces of the men who've liked me because I was fat, not in spite of it, the BBW fetishists who mask objectification in a paper thin layer of desire.  The man who rubbed himself on my belly fat before I knew what was happening, and to whom I was too shocked and ashamed to object.  The one who disappointedly says "you've lost weight" when I get naked, even though I haven't.

On this screen, I walk in to the eye doctor I visit annually for a checkup, as I have been doing for 30 years.  I got my first pair of glasses in 6th grade, then later contacts.  I had Lasik when I was 25 or 26 and still have 20/20 vision.  Five years ago, I was diagnosed with a condition that affected my vision and optic nerves.  I have been asymptomatic for several years now, the condition has resolved.

And yet.

He tells me to lose weight.

The heat creeps over my skin, the neon sign in my brain flashing "evidence based care???" so brightly I'm surprised he can't see it and explain himself.

He has me come back a month later for a visual field test and an OCT.  When he walks into the room, he makes a pleased-sounding comment about how I'm losing weight.

(I'm not.)

Everything looks good.  Normal, even. But at the end of the appointment, he tells me to lose weight.

Despite the fact that he is an optometrist, and not my general practitioner.

Despite the fact that I do not show any symptoms of the one condition I've ever had that it would be appropriate for him to comment on.

Despite the fact that when I was at the height of my illness, I DID lose weight, on an awful, miserable meal replacement plan, and it didn't affect or improve my condition in any way.

Despite the fact that for all intents and purposes, I appear to be completely in remission.

Despite the fact that I am a 37 year old adult woman, and surely he cannot think he is the FIRST PERSON IN THE WORLD to remind me that I am fat and that's not okay with people.

Because it's "really important."

To whom?

To him?  Is this not my own body?  Does it matter what I want, how I feel, whether there is any evidence that losing weight would make me less likely to have too much spinal fluid once again?

To the world at large?  Because I am offensive?  Because if you are fat and sick, you must be sick because you are fat, and if you are fat and not sick, it's just a matter of time?

Instead of saying any of this, I nod my head in compliance, my nerves burning hot under my skin as I walk out the door.

This is one day.  This is one image in the museum.  This is bullshit, and these are the moments I choose to leave this wing whenever I can.  Like Plum, my self-doubt has largely turned to anger.

Plum:  I hate being like this.
Verena:  What if it’s not you that’s the problem?  What if it’s everybody else that needs to change? What if it’s not you that’s wrong, it’s them?

The path I walk is not the path of least resistance, there are switchbacks and there are snares.  I surround myself with people who are like me, and we grow and learn together, they inspire me little by little to believe that I am worth more.  I try to believe in myself, and some days I can do it.

Other days, I look around me, and all I see is Dietland.

4.10.2018

Get your tropes off my lawn

Ready Player One was one of my favorite books of last year, I listened to the audio book and enjoyed it so much that immediately upon finishing it I couldn't wait for it to be a movie.  We went and saw it last weekend and I enjoyed it.  Well, most of it.  To be honest, I haven't gotten the following line out of my head:

Aech: Z, you gotta be more careful about who you meet out on the OASIS.  I'm serious. She could actually be a 300 pound dude who lives in his momma's basement in suburban Detroit. And her name is Chuck.

SAD TROMBONE.

Here's the thing.  That's me, there in the picture.  Do I look like a disgusting slob who lives in my mom's basement tricking people on the internet?  Do I look like the worst possible thing you can think of?  Because I am about three small bags of flour away from 300 pounds. 

Last time I went to the doctor, I weighed in at 291.

Does that surprise you?

This is far from the first time I've heard this exact thing, and I am 100% sure it won't be the last.  So how am I supposed to feel in the theater, or on my couch watching TV, or reading a book, when the number I would see on my scale is used as an example of pretty much the worst thing that could happen to a person?  When 300 pounds means unclean, unworthy, unlovable, unimaginable?

Next time you need to describe what someone should be afraid of, wary of, careful of... it would be nice if you didn't use me and hundreds of other normal people like me, as an example.  It's hurtful and disappointing and unrealistic and so many other things.

It's bad enough that I rarely see anyone who looks like me in any type of entertainment.  The fat people I do see are either there to laugh at or to represent how gross fat people are, to make eating jokes about, to fall over and be clumsy, or like on This is Us they are completely obsessed with losing weight.  Can we just be done with the fat-basement-recluse who's hiding behind the internet because no one in their right mind would want to come face to face with such a hideous specimen?




1.16.2018

The Urge

It rises from within like water bubbling through layers of silt, that familiar urge.  Pulling at my mind and heart, self-doubt wrapped in guilt and colored muddy with anxious fear.

Take it back.

Words flew from my lips and fingertips sparked by passion and feelings of righteousness and being tired of the same. old. thing.

Smooth it over.

What is a voice for, if not to be used?  I have found myself in a new year, screaming louder than ever before, caring less and less what people think.  When I first dubbed 2018 the year of not giving a fuck what other people think, I was kind of joking.

It has only taken a week to realize I'm not joking.

Am I supposed to be a certain way?  When I think about what is expected of me, I see pictures and words.

Skinny.  Compliant.  Agreeable.  Ladylike.  Peacekeeper.  Forgiving.

These are not the words that light the fire within me.  I can feel my passion rising to the point of overtaking me, and I've never felt such power.

Apologize.

But, for what?  I have done nothing wrong.  This urge to silence my own voice is as infuriating as it is ridiculous, and it has been ground into me year after year, experience after experience.

But they might be mad... upset... at me...

It is not my job to make you feel better about the things you don't understand.  It is not my job to re-assure you that I know YOU aren't the bad guy.  It is not my job to walk you through examining your part in this story.  It is time for me to write MY part.

It is not I who does not understand.  I have been overlooked and pushed aside because of what lies between my legs and beneath my skin.

Look, I'm not trying to say...

The more I look, the more there are.  I tear up reading The Militant Baker.  I am wholly inspired by Anna, her look, her kindness, her positivity, and her unapologetic commitment to being who she is.  I devour Shrill, the way you devour a book you're unable to put down because there they are - the words you had inside you and didn't know how to say.

I am not alone.

I don't think you're a bad person...

I am starting to understand that it is okay to love myself.  It is okay, even, if that means that I am not always nice, that I don't have to let people off the hook for things they didn't mean or didn't think about.  There can be no change without realization.  There can be no progress without self-examination.

I know you don't mean to be hurtful...

My dreams have changed, they have morphed, they run ahead of me like sprites laughing in the sun, calling me to catch up with them.  I have new heroes now, and to join their ranks would be an honor.

I don't mean to be confrontational...

I don't?  I think... I do.  I think 37 years in, it's about time for a big damn confrontation.

10.05.2015

The Fattest Girl in the Room

I am often the fattest girl in the room.

I am the fattest one in my group of girlfriends.  I am the fattest one in my immediate family.  I am the fattest one in my office at work.

There are days when I look in the mirror, and I wonder what the big deal is.  I look at myself, and I see a human being, a woman, perhaps taking up a bit more space than average, but in the grand scheme of things, not that large.  Some days I look in the mirror and think, I'm just fine.  Some days I even like myself.

Other days I look in the mirror and all I see is that I am not good enough.  That I am too fat.  That there are places on my body that roll and drape and pillow and dimple where they should be flat and smooth and tight.  My hips are wide, my ass is expansive.  My breasts are bigger than they used to be because I've gained weight, and I like that part, but I don't like so much that if I lean back just right I can feel a part of my back touching another part of my back that I didn't used to be able to feel.

There are days when I put on a pretty outfit, where I find a shirt that flatters me, and I feel confident, and pretty.  I find a shirt that matches my eyes and it looks so good the way it cinches in just below my bust then flows out, not clinging to the parts of me I don't want to highlight.  I put on earrings and brush my hair, and feel like I might be able to take on anything.

Other days I try to go clothes shopping and hours and hours of looking and trying results only in feeling upset and frustrated because clothes just are not made for this body.  Yes, there are "plus sized" clothes out there.  I am 5'7" tall, and when I go to Lane Bryant, most of the pants are still 2-3 inches too long for me.  So... am I supposed to be an amazon?  Because last time I checked the average height for women was like... 5'4"?  Most of the shirts and dresses available there gape in the chest, because even with the weight I've gained, I am usually still a C cup, definitely no bigger than a D.

Plus size clothes are made for women who are proportionately larger.  Women who are 6 feet tall and have a 45 inch waist, but not for women like me.  There are few clothes out there made for a woman with pretty shoulders and thin ankles, but bulky thighs, wide hips and ass, and a lot of weight on the front.  I carry much of my weight around my middle, especially in the front.

I look in the mirror, and I do not think I am that far outside the norm, so I wonder, WHERE are the clothes for women like me?

Do you want to know a secret?  I am more comfortable naked than I am clothed.  I have been naked in front of men, and friends, and people who I don't know well, and felt completely at ease.  When I am naked, all I am is myself.  My shape is not WRONG when I am naked, it just is how it is.  When I am naked, I feel normal.  When I try to squash and push and shove myself into clothes not made for me, it can be hard to feel even a semblance of normal.

Some days I try to get dressed and put on two or three outfits before I settle and feel comfortable and like I can be seen in public.

I have stretch marks on my stomach, my arms, and my breasts.  Some days, I run my fingers over that shiny soft skin and I kind of like how it feels.  When you gain and lose 50 pounds or more multiple times in relatively short time periods, these squiggly reminders are inevitable.  Some women call them tiger stripes.  Mostly women who are thinner than me, I think, and see their stretch marks as their largest imperfection.

There are days when I feel beautiful.  Where my boyfriend calls me his pretty girl, or one of my friends tells me how lovely I am, or where I look in the mirror and see my happiness written on my skin like a beautiful song.

Other days, I don't think men find me desirable, or the ones who do fetishize me, ask me if I am a BBW.  I am not a BBW, I am just a W.  If you think I'm beautiful, maybe I'm a BW, but why do you need to have a term for women who are larger?  It makes me feel like you ONLY like me because I am fat.  Or, they tell me that I'm not fat, which is just as bad, because come on, dude.  I am fat, and being fat and beautiful don't have to be mutually exclusive... right?

There are days when I rage, inside my head.  I think, who are all of these people to tell me that I am not worth looking at?  Who are they to tell me that I am not good enough, that I am not enough? Who are they to tell me that I don't have just as much right to happiness as they do? Fuck them!  I am a human being, a beautiful one, inside and out.  I am pretty, and smart, and worth looking at, worth loving.

Other days, I just hate being the fattest one in the room.  Knowing that other women see me and feel relieved because they aren't the fat one.  Seeing things online or in magazines or just around out in the world that make it very clear to me that my fat, the shape of me, makes me a BURDEN on society.  There are days that I know that people look at me as the problem. People look at me, and think I deserve less because I am... lazy. Ugly. Slobby. Not trying. Not caring. Fat. Obese. Disgusting.  These days, it is perfectly clear to me that I am doing something to other people just by existing in this body.

There are days when I think about losing weight, yes.  There are days when I think of joining the YMCA and counting calories, and the fact that I haven't stepped on a scale in probably two months because my highest weight in the past was 267, and I'm about 99% sure that isn't actually true anymore.

Other days I think about how it has always been extremely hard for me to lose weight because of various metabolic issues I have, and it makes me feel defeated before I even begin.  I worry that working out a few times a week and cutting back on calories wouldn't even make a dent.  I'm not sure I would handle the disappointment very well.  It's really hard to try so hard, and put so much effort into something, for so little result.  Some days I think about how I am not behind in my bills, and maybe I should just do Medifast for a couple of months and lose weight that way.  It doesn't seem like the healthiest way, but at the same time, I know I could DO it.

There are days when I tell myself that if I lose weight it will be for me.  To feel more comfortable, to be able to do things that I want to do that require more flexibility and stamina.

Other days, I am angry.  I don't know if I want to lose weight at all.  I wonder if I only think those things because I am SUPPOSED to want to be skinnier and better.  I am angry that fat shaming is a thing, and if you don't think it's a thing, you're probably not fat.  It's pervasive, and insulting, and minimizing.  I wonder if I only think about being less fat because people have told me, to my face, or just through action and culture, that I am NOT GOOD ENOUGH.  That if I am fat, I should WANT to lose weight, because being skinnier is being better.  I am angry that I am judged, and I want to throw it in their faces, and say, no, I will not change myself for you.  I am happy.

But, the fattest girl in the room is not the happy girl.  She is not the one who glows and laughs and smiles.  She is not the one who gets the boy in the end.  She is not the one with the high powered job and nice car and fashionable clothes.

I am not supposed to be happy.  I am the fattest girl in the room.

5.22.2014

Open Letter to a Fat Shamer

Dear Fat Shamer,

This is to you and all the other standup gents that think it's somehow their job to get on dating websites and send messages such as the following:
why didn't you tell me AFF is adult fat finder?  Cannot believe the women and their photos... what world do you live in?
I live in a world where grown men who feel rejected deal with it by lashing out and trying to hurt people they don't even know to make themselves feel better.  Since the first message you send me said Hi and had a more friendly tone, I can only assume that you were angry that 8 hours later, I hadn't responded?  So you decided that you weren't interested anyway, because I'm too fat for you?  And were unable to consider the idea that maybe I hadn't checked my messages for the last 8 hours?  I don't really know what series of thoughts took place in your head to make you decide to send this second message, but let me tell you about the world I live in.

I live in a world where men like yourself think it's okay to send hateful, negative messages asking me how I could possibly dare to want to date or experience physical intimacy given my weight.  Couldn't I just as easily ask you how you could dare to message me when you are balding?  Because, in what world would any woman find that attractive?!  But I wouldn't do that.  For a lot of reasons, including the fact that I have been with balding men who were dead sexy.  Also, because I don't judge people or shame them for the fact that they don't have much hair.  And mostly because I'm not a rude, vindictive jerk.

I live in a world where not everything is perfect.  Not that it's any of your business, but I do struggle with my weight, and there are a lot of medical and psychological reasons for that.  Besides, that doesn't matter.  If you don't like girls who are curvy, soft, big, FAT, then just move on to someone else.  There's no need to be hostile.

I live in a world where people like you see me as a LESS THAN because my body weight is a little more than you think it should be.  Where I am looked down on because you find me unattractive.  Where to you, my weight means that I should be alone, that I don't deserve to have men like me, that I don't deserve to feel sexy, that I don't deserve intimacy or pleasure.  That I don't even deserve to be treated with common courtesy.  

How exactly do you expect me to respond to this?

I'm sorry that you have decided the best way to spend your time is sending negative, angry, rude messages to strangers.  If you were trying to hurt my feelings, it didn't work.  Do you know why?  Because I already KNOW I am fat.  Did you think that it would be some big surprise to me that 1.  I am fat or 2. Some men are not attracted to me?  Are you crazy?  Why do you think I have a full body shot on my profile?  Transparency.  The idea of it is that people like you, who only prefer one type of woman, will not contact me.

Here's a newsflash for you.  There are plenty of men who find me attractive just the way I am.  Do I want to lose weight?  Of course I do.  How could I not, given the culture that I live in and the fact that I'm surrounded by the media and people like you every day telling me how disgusting and worthless I am?  Of course I want to be healthier.  Of course I want to fit in.  Of course I want to be desired.  But I'm only human, and plans don't always work out.  Besides, if there is one thing I have learned in the past 5 months it is that I can meet men who value my mind along with my body, and who also love the way my curves look and feel.

You're obviously having trouble getting a date, but I'm not.  I live in a world where I don't need to worry about men like you, because all you are is a bully, and I left that shit behind in grade school.

You're a 40 year old man, why don't you start acting like one.